All products featured on Epicurious are independently selected by our editors. To find out which company offers the best ice cream sandwich, we sampled eight different varieties, all available online or in stores. Testers loved the nostalgic feel of this ice cream sandwich brand—the gooey, sticky cookie and the super-sweet ice cream. Ice cream sandwiches have come a long way since they were first invented in 1899 in New York City, and now you can eat them infused with Campari, vermouth, and juniper sandwiched between two slices of vanilla cake, like a Negroni cocktail, or with miso salt caramel ice cream sandwiched between Guinness cake. Before we dive into the world of ice cream sandwiches, a note about nomenclature: In the lead up to this story, I asked several random acquaintances what they would call the chocolate part (in some circles known as the best part) of a traditional ice cream sandwich. Epicurious may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. But in the case of the ice cream sandwich, simpler is better. But with a dizzying array of ice cream sandwiches available in stores, it may be difficult for some consumers to decide which brand has the best take on this classic summertime dessert. We sampled 14 brands of chocolate–and-vanilla ice cream sandwiches, but only a few of them melted our hearts. The classic Chipwich, so touted as “The Original Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich,” brought back a lot of fond childhood memories for us, and definitely came out as one of the top contenders. If you require a classic-sized sandwich, or even an organic one, you're in luck—we chose the best-in-category for those, too. For our methodology and the full list of sandos we tasted, scroll to the bottom of the page. When we set out to find the best ice cream sandwich, a few people asked if we'd include sandwiches made with chocolate chip cookies. Some called it a cookie. If you crave a super-classic ICS, this is the ultimate option. The first thing that struck us about the Fat Boy ice cream sandwich — besides the brand's interesting name choice — was its shape. Together, those two components gave our tasters the deeply satisfying experience every ice cream sandwich should provide. It also has that paper wrapper that's actually kind of hard to peel off, but for nostalgic folks, maybe that's part of the fun? Others called it cake. Ultimately we wanted a wafer with deep chocolate flavor and a nice chewy consistency. First up, the rankings! BUY IT: Turkey Hill Premium Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Sandwiches, $5 for six (4-ounce) sandwiches on Instacart. Call them small but mighty: these sandwiches boast both a deeply chocolaty and nicely chewy wafer, and a light, creamy, vanilla-rich ice cream. Information about your device and internet connection, including your IP address, Browsing and search activity while using Verizon Media websites and apps. #themoreyouknow, So that's the term we used in our official taste test. We also tossed out any flavor other than the classic vanilla—no strawberry, no cookies 'n' cream, and definitely no sandwiches made with Neapolitan. The vanilla ice cream in these sandwiches has a homemade quality about it. (We also tasted both mini and "regular" versions from two out of the 11 brands represented—and despite common logic, those minis did not taste the same as their larger counterparts.). Any wafers deemed too crisp fell in the rankings (when the wafer's too hard, it squishes the ice cream out out of the sandwich). BUY IT: Alden's Organic Vanilla Bean Round Sammies, $6 for four (3.5-ounce) sandwiches on Instacart. Instead of the traditional rectangle, this sandwich was square and had more ice cream packed between the cookies. It sports a deeply chocolaty and chewy wafer, melty ice cream with real vanilla bean flecks, and—unlike our other two picks—it's rectangular. Score: 5.6 For that classic ice cream sandwich—you know, the kind served at school picnics and kids' parties—turn to Nestlé. Note: ice cream sandwiches make a particularly terrible substitute for building blocks.

Wilkinson Mini Humbucker, Best Social Media Marketing Agency, Butter Mochi Microwave Recipe, Dawlance Fridge Small Size Price In Pakistan 2020, List Of Electrical Engineering Companies In Canada, Honey Balsamic Glaze For Veggies, Questions To Ask Before Becoming An Insurance Agent, Virtual Memory Windows 7, Clear Crossbody Bag, Ahs Text Meaning, Teal Leather Sectional, How To Test Garage Door Sensors,